I won't buy this book ever. However, I thoroughly enjoy/enjoyed Karen's book. Her reviews were spot on and objective.

These guys come out of the gate with the show as "right-wing". What the heck are you even watching dudes? That tells me they're taking Five-O completely out of context. It was made in the 1970s for gosh's sakes!

I think it's less left-wing and more smugness - the very smugness they talk about McGarrett having. "It's our book" reeks of arrogance, no matter their political leanings. I have both right-wing and left-wing leaning friends and NONE of them reek of this kind of arrogance. The authors are just being stupid.